A difference in the two stories is the main characters, della (the gift of the magi) and mathilde loisel (the necklace) della is a loving wife who works the comparison and contrast of developmental theories nichole spiller psy 104: child and adolescent development instructor: sonja bethune. 'the gift of the magi' by o henry and 'the necklace' by guy de maupassant are two short stories that share some similarities the husband in 'the necklace' is a 'thrifty clerk' who doesn't like to spend too much money after implored by his wife, he gives her the money that he saved up for a rifle. Comparison essay the two short stories, the gift of the magi written by o henry and the necklace written by guy de maupassant are both composed of two young, beautiful women mathilde and della even though they are in different composed stories that have similar characteristics that.
The love and the affection were still there while some see gifts as only a matter of material and money, the gift of the magi suggests that gifts that are given don't matter as much as the love behind them does, because gifts are a sign of love between people. The end of the story is also interesting as henry appears to be introducing irony into the story the reader is already aware that for della there were two though some critics might suggest that both gifts are now of no use the point that henry may be making is that the real gift that both della and.
The biggest irony on the gift of the magi is not evident till the end however, this surprising twist adds depth and appeal to the story till close to the end, it is only della's story that continues her hair, her sacrifice, her love, her longing and her gift a first time reader would imagine a different end to. There are many differences in the gift of the magi, by o henry and the diamond necklace, by guy de maupassant, there are also various similarities some of the similarities include being set around the same time of year, winter, both set at the turn of century, both couples have the same economic. The themes of these two stories are very similar the gift of the magi is about a poor couple who are satisfied with what they have they do not dream about buying something for themselves but each other.
The gift of the magi is a short story, written by o henry (a pen name for william sydney porter), about a young husband and wife and how they deal with the challenge of buying secret christmas gifts for each other with very little money. Commonlit has identified one or more texts from our collection to pair with the gift of the magi, based on similar themes, literary devices, topic, or writing style supplement your lesson with one or more of these options and challenge students to compare and contrast the texts.
The story of the gift of the magi deftly displays powerful themes of love, sacrifice, and the concept of true value and worth he died from cirrhosis of the liver, diabetes, and an enlarged heart o henry wrote and published dozens of short stories, including the ransom of red chief, the cop and the. Free summary and analysis of the events in o henry's the gift of the magi that won't make you snore we promise and the next day is christmas faced with such a situation, della promptly bursts into tears on the couch, which gives the narrator the opportunity to tell us a bit more about the. Paragraph five of the gift of the magi evokes the connotation between long names and the upper echelons of society that is, royalty, professionals, and those belonging to the upper classes 1 educator answer. That is the case in the gift of the magi and the necklace the short stories give clues about their financial struggles maupassant tells the story from the wife's point of view we learn that mme loisel was born into a poor family and because she had no dowry, she married a not so wealthy man.
The narrator of the gift of the magi is non-participant it can be said the gift of the magi has the theme sacrifice sometimes can be pointless i could tell that since della's sacrifice to cut her hair off to buy the chain for jim's watch became pointless because in the end, jim told della that he had. Jim, della's husband, and the lord of the flat, is only twenty-two and heavily burdened by the need to support the household on a low salary the timeline below shows where the character jim appears in the gift of the magi the colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that. They invented the art of giving christmas presents being wise, their gifts were no doubt wise ones, possibly bearing the privilege of exchange in case of duplication and here i have lamely related to you the uneventful chronicle of two foolish children in a flat who most unwisely sacrificed for each other.