'so long as the english tongue survives, the word dunkirk will be spoken with reverence in that harbour, such a hell on earth as never blazed before, at the end of a lost battle, the rags and blemishes that had hidden the soul of democracy fell away. Frances occupation of tunisia, dunkirk triumph disaster essay best thesis statement writing website law assignment help onlinewhy essay is funcontrolling idea essays best report editing sites for college essay writer essay about moving to another statetype my top creative writing. The fact that you ask why was dunkirk considered a disaster says volumes of how good british propaganda has been and still is, propagating misleading information and refusing to publicly accept the fact that dunkirk was an unmitigated disaster of biblical proportions. Many people also believed that dunkirk was a disaster it was a disaster in a number of ways firstly, there were many casualties in the battle 68,000 of the british expeditionary force perished during the barrage, along with about a quarter of the remaining french military.
During dunkirk, had germany made a determined effort to destroy the army of the allies, the war would not have been won due to the huge number of losses that would have been incurred by the allies as it was, the french had lost thousands of tonnes of equipment and more men during the battle for france and calais, and so had the brits. It was the cheering, not the battle, for which dunkirk was remembered in strictly were left behind), the british forged a propaganda triumph the battle of dunkirk was hugely important as it allowed the allies to keep a considerable military force which later went on to become part of the allies advance during the d-day landings. Sources a, b and c all give information about what happened at the battle of dunkirk and about the evacuation all three sources were written by british people which means that the sources could be biased or contain incorrect information. Essay about the battle of dunkirk: a tactical defeat 1616 words | 7 pages the battle of dunkirk happened in northern france between may 26 and june 4 1940 and was a major battle of the second world war which occurred between 1939-1945.
Dunkirk stands out as a triumph for england because it showed that it would not quit and the eventual defeat of nazi germany can be traced back to this miracle at dunkirk as it showed strength and stopped the nazi's from attack great britain further and it gave them breathing space. To conclude i personally do not fully and entirely agree with the statement 'dunkirk was a triumph' i agree with the fact that it was a miracle and an amazing effort that the british were able to evacuate most of its soldiers from dunkirk. Dunkirk was both a triumph and a disaster operation dynamo, saved the british army from being captured by the german army,but the british army was put out of battle of france, leaving france to be killed off by germany.
- the events at dunkirk in june 1940 it is very difficult to give a direct answer about whether dunkirk was or was not a crushing victory for the german army some sources agree with this interpretation and suggest that it was a great victory for hitler. The battle of dunkirk lasted from around may 25 to june 3, 1940 after the phony war, the battle of france began on 10 may, 1940 german armour burst through the ardennes region and advanced rapidly driving north in the so-called sickle cut. This feature is not available right now please try again later.
Essay - 1138 words free essay: dunkirk battle could be called a failure or success depending on the viewpoint from 27th may to 4th june the british expeditionary nbsp was dunkirk a triumph - gcse history - marked by was a triumph of a defeat. The battle of france, of which dunkirk was the final chapter, was a disaster, although eduardo j belgrano's description of 'unmitigated' is incorrect the evacuation, operation dynamo, was conceived, planned and began operation in six days. In this essay i will be viewing and analysing two different interpretations of the events that took place in dunkirk 1940 on one hand some believe that the occurrence in dunkirk that took place was a great triumph for the british army, air force and navy services.
The battle of dunkirk can be seen as both a triumph and a failure it will never be possible to say the answer is just one or the other it can be seen as a triumph by the fact the british and french survived, which is a triumph in itself, as by seeing the predicament they were facing, it was likely they were going to lose. Dunkirk- not a triumph many people also believed that dunkirk was a disaster it was a disaster in a number of ways firstly, there were many casualties in the battle 68,000 of the british expeditionary force perished during the barrage, along with about a quarter of the remaining french military. Metropolitan france is situated mostly between latitudes 41° and 51° n (dunkirk is just north of 51°), and longitudes 6° w and10° e, on the western edge of europe, and thus lies within the northern temperate zone from southwest. Dunkirk was a harbour that was situated at the far north of france where the battle between the germans and the allies had been left there it was late may 1940 when german forces advanced their way into northern france, forcing british and french troops to pull back.
Another encouraging idea to come out of dunkirk was that although it was a military defeat, it was a big propaganda victory this notion is identified in source b12, which is a bbc news reporter commenting (in a bbc television broadcast) on the 60th anniversary of dunkirk in the year 2000. The battle of dunkirk essay example - the battle of dunkirk who could have ever imagined 'dunkirk' a word containing only a few letters, a word which caused immense havoc, annihilation, death and suffering could signify something so powerful, a word of great reverence, a word of saviour, hope and spirit for the british. Dunkirk wasnt a traditional x vs y battle, but an inevitable siege and retreat one, and was of that nature right from the start thus, from this point of view it was somewhat of a triumph, as the vast majority of men trapped in the pocket managed to escape. The evidence that shows that dunkirk was a triumph is in the cinemas, movie tone news reported it like this this was reported at the time of dunkirk: 'more cheering evidence of the success of this amazing military exploit is the presence in britain of large numbers of french soldiers.
Free essay: dunkirk battle could be called a failure or success depending on the viewpoint from 27th may to 4th june the british expeditionary force with. This interpretation is correct in the sense that dunkirk was a triumph and a disaster it was written by ajp taylor although at the time of dunkirk it was only seen by people as a great triumph.