Effectiveness of torture in the context of war on terror

Circumstances of the case, such as the nature and context of the treatment, its duration, its physical and mental effects and, in some circumstances, the sex, age and state of health of the victim. After 9//11 and the beginning of a global war on terror, the department of justice, department of defense and other offices of the bush administration issued a number of reports on whether aggressive detainee interrogation practices and suspending geneva conventions is legitimate in the current context. Like many other detainees in the war on terror, there was no actual evidence linking him to terrorist activities 8 so arar's experience belies the first portion of the myth the myth states that all who are tortured are terrorists. The context of crimes against humanity and war crimes, each of which carry additional and more complicated elements than the basic crime of torture national courts are further critical to civil remedies for torture.

In defense of torture by sam harris 130 note: while we hold the moral high ground in our war on terror, we appear to hold it less and less in this context, we should note that many. The war on terrorism was a multidimensional campaign of almost limitless scope its military dimension involved major wars in afghanistan and iraq , covert operations in yemen and elsewhere, large-scale military-assistance programs for cooperative regimes, and major increases in military spending. In the context of an actual war, a recognized war, nation-states are able to do what they don't get to do in peacetime, like hold people without all of the indicia of due process that we require lee so a prisoner of war camp, for example, something we think of historically as temporary or onsite during a conflict. For the united states in the war on terror, accountability has meant little other than prosecuting the so-called 'bad apples' who conduct torture and/or murder in order to make the point that they.

The costs of war project is a team of 35 scholars, legal experts, human rights practitioners, and physicians, which began its work in 2011 we use research and a public website to facilitate debate about the costs of the post-9/11 wars in iraq, afghanistan, and pakistan. It would be naïve to think that the uk personnel haven't participated in torture over the last 500 years, but between 2001 and 2010, the uk was part of a sustained, planned and coordinated campaign of torture in the name of the so-called 'war on terror. This is an authoritative conclusion, said philippe sands, a law professor at university college, london and the author of torture team, an account of how torture came to be used increasingly on al-qaida suspects in the wake of 9/11 the senate intelligence commission has been looking into this for several years.

According to the report, the discrepancies in hayden's 2007 testimony involved the scope of the use of enhanced interrogation, its effectiveness in producing useful intelligence, screening and training processes for interrogators and dissent within the ranks, among other issues. To torture a suspect once who consequently reveals like-saving information which then is exploited successfully describes an instance in which torture is tactically effective but in the context of asymmetric warfare, such as the current war on terror, effectiveness refers to the degree torture lessens the asymmetric threat or gives to those threatened a strategic advantage over time. The prohibition of torture face in this context since the united states have been the leading state in the war on terror, this paper will focus mainly on its acts. 108 parameters 46(1) spring 2016 overview on measuring policy effectiveness in general and the war on terror, in particular, follows the data are analyzed in section three and. Yvonne ridley is a journalist and author whose focus on modern war studies is borne out of her ordeal of being captured by the ruling taliban in afghanistan shortly after the 9/11 attacks in 2001.

Torture has been used throughout history for the purpose of obtaining information in interrogationtorture, while widely illegal and a violation of international law, has been frequently cited as generating false or misleading information, and lacks scientific evidence supporting its effectiveness. Researchers in communication studies and political science found that american understanding of the war on terror is directly shaped by how mainstream news media reports events associated with the conflict. The war on terror launched after september 11, 2001 has renewed a philosophical and political debate, in the united states and elsewhere, about whether torture is ever justified. Thirteen years after the september 11 attacks cia torture and the war on terror 11 september 2014 today marks the thirteenth anniversary of the terrorist attacks of september 11, 2001. 2 time-honored traditions of war, the geneva convention, and a long list of other interna-tional treaties, to hold that the government had authority under the authorization for.

Effectiveness of torture in the context of war on terror

effectiveness of torture in the context of war on terror Dr lisa hajjar, professor of sociology at the university of california santa barbara, discusses the afterlives of torture: putting the us 'war on terror' in historical and global context on wednesday, nov 8, from 5 to 6:30 pm in schoonover 145.

Asked about deficits in the justice system in relation to torture, he said that in the context of counter-terrorism, excessive use of pre-trial detention without sufficient monitoring was the main. 2002), and torture as a tool of war or counterterrorism the latter included excellent studies on torture by the french in algeria (vidal-naquet 1963, 1972), the british in northern. Torture and cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment are gross violations of human rights and should be universally condemned even if torture wasn't a codified crime against humanity, it rarely, if ever, garners useful information television programs such as lost and 24 fostered the myth of torture's utility to save the day. In the context of war and counter terrorism some countries allow the abuse of prisoners as a means to prevent attacks or locate high profile targets in this case the welfare and protection of the country (many) legitimizes the harm done to one or few.

  • The absolute prohibition against torture is a jus cogens 1 international norm that is observed widely under international human rights and humanitarian law 2 yet, revelations that the bush administration employed waterboarding, stress positions, wall standing and exposure to loud music during interrogations in the 'war on terror' have raised questions over the robustness of the torture.
  • War, terror, and torture war is the father of all, and king of all and some it shows as gods, others as men some it makes slaves, others free heraclitus of ephesus, fragment 215, the presocratic philosophers.
  • The ig report was declassified in august 2009 and is the first substantial insider body of evidence on the use of torture in the war on terror, by those directly involved in the process of justifying and then applying torture methods.

Whether targeting a boko haram suspect, an alleged criminal, a sex worker, or simply part of a minority group, a new amnesty international report highlights how torture is endemic in nigeria as the police and military routinely use it to extract confessions, extort money and to break the will of detainees.

effectiveness of torture in the context of war on terror Dr lisa hajjar, professor of sociology at the university of california santa barbara, discusses the afterlives of torture: putting the us 'war on terror' in historical and global context on wednesday, nov 8, from 5 to 6:30 pm in schoonover 145. effectiveness of torture in the context of war on terror Dr lisa hajjar, professor of sociology at the university of california santa barbara, discusses the afterlives of torture: putting the us 'war on terror' in historical and global context on wednesday, nov 8, from 5 to 6:30 pm in schoonover 145.
Effectiveness of torture in the context of war on terror
Rated 5/5 based on 44 review

2018.